Showing posts with label FINRA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label FINRA. Show all posts

Friday, August 10, 2012

THE CLUELESS SEC


The Clueless Securities and Exchange Commission
Ellen Ullman explains:
AS a former software engineer, I laughed when I read what the Securities and Exchange Commission might be considering in response to the debacle of Knight Capital’s runaway computerized stock trades: forcing companies to fully test their computer systems before deploying coding changes.

That policy may sound sensible, but if you know anything about computers, it is funny on several accounts.

First, it is impossible to fully test any computer system. To think otherwise is to misunderstand what constitutes such a system. It is not a single body of code created entirely by one company. Rather, it is a collection of “modules” plugged into one another. Software modules are purchased from multiple vendors; the programs are proprietary; a purchaser (like Knight Capital) cannot see this code. Each piece of hardware also has its own embedded, inaccessible programming. The resulting system is a tangle of black boxes wired together that communicate through dimly explained “interfaces.” A programmer on one side of an interface can only hope that the programmer on the other side has gotten it right.

Next, there is no such thing as a body of code without bugs. You can test assiduously: first the programmers test, then the quality-assurance engineers; finally you run the old and new systems in parallel to monitor results. But no matter. There is always one more bug. Society may want to put its trust in computers, but it should know the facts: a bug, fix it. Another bug, fix it. The “fix” itself may introduce a new bug. And so on.

So now consider that tangle of modules. The bug in one meets the bug in another, and that one in another ... and the possibility of system failure multiplies exponentially.

Another absurd thing is trying to define a coding change worth fully testing. A completely new system rollout would certainly qualify. How about installing an updated module from one of those software vendors? It depends on the perceived criticality of the component. How about that new network router and its embedded code? Rarely done. What about a tiny bug fix done by a responsible, hardworking programmer at Knight Capital? Good quality-assurance departments would test that. But individual programmers may see a particular change as insignificant. One time I fixed a function by changing “less than” to “less than or equal to.” That “fix” propagated through the system. And down the system came.
This is a pretty obvious case of how the SEC is clueless, but there are many other instances, especially where security regulations are on the books. In many, many cases, the SEC has no clue as to how sharp operators are using regulations to their advantage---and to the detriment of everyone else.

The SEC should be shut down and securities regulations should be thrown into the garbage dump. This would eliminate the moat that protects the big Wall Street firms from new competitors. Wall Street would be a much better, more honest and more interesting place, without the SEC. You would be able to actual pick between thousands of firms, as opposed to be railroaded into dealing with the crooks at Goldman Sachs, JPMorgan Chase and Citigroup.

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Court Reverses SEC Victory in SEC v. Goble


COURT OF APPEAL THROWS OUT SEC’S FRAUD CHARGES AGAINST RICHARD GOBLE
Court of appeals vindicates former FINRA Board Member and Head of North American Clearing
The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals today threw out charges of Securities fraud and a permanent bar against former FINRA board member Richard Goble after hearing his case on appeal.  After fighting charges from the SEC for nearly four years Goble has been vindicated of the most serious charges, although the court did find he aided and abetted North American in  the net cap computation of the firm. Goble was not the financial operator of the firm, and the violations left intact have been described by SIPA members as tantamount to a warning from the mailman not to park your car in front of a mail box. Goble was the owner of North American Clearing and one of the founders of the Financial Industry Association (FIA). The FIA was shut down immediately by the regulators when the SEC and a court appointed receiver arrived at North American's place of business in May 2008. In addition to closing the FIA web site and servers, the SEC and the court appointed receiver confiscated millions of dollars from the accounts of North American and used those funds to pay legal fees totaling nearly $ 5 million dollars. Today is actually the four year anniversary of the SEC shutting down North American Clearing and it now appears the firm was closed for watering their lawn on the wrong day of the week. In addition to the losses suffered by Goble, dozens of FINRA brokerage firms lost millions of dollars in settlement accounts that were used by the receiver to pay legal fees.
The recent news of executives fighting the SEC, who has decided to go after executives and lawyers in addition to the companies they work for, and the Commission’s destruction of documents in its investigations of large U.S. Banks’ role in the 2008 Crisis has sparked controversy over the agency’s effectiveness.
Sources: www.thesipa.com